1.11.02 CFC Meetings notes

Attendance: (11) Maurice, Julian, Lynne, Kaye, Keith, Don, Chris, Jesse, Olin, Saul, Ms Washington, Mike

Navy Proposed ESD for Parcel B

Comments to the Navy‚s document are due on Thursday, January 17

The document covers two Navy proposed clean-up actions on Parcel B

After receive comments the Navy can: (1) make changes to the proposed plan and resubmit

(2) Decide not to make changes and go ahead with proposed plan

Parcel B shoreline

The current contract:

Navy build a temporary wall to block out water. After building the wall the Navy is required to clean up the shoreline. Possible cost $5-10 million

Navy‚s proposed changes:

Capsulate Parcel B shoreline will concrete. Roughly a few hundred feet long and 10 feet deep would be covered in concrete. Cost less than 5 million dollars.

Unanswered questions/concerns:

· Navy ESD document needs to provide more details on shoreline protection remedy

· What is being protected? What is being encapsulated?

· No idea how deep contamination goes down, Navy proposal would go only 10 feet.

· State regulators want the Navy to clean shoreline and oppose encapsulating shoreline

· Federal regulators no position yet, want more information

· City supports encapsulation if the plan works, City wants to clean up Parcel B soon, so transfer of Parcel B can occur

CFC Next Steps

1. Draft individual letters to Navy commenting on Navy proposed changes

2. Contact R. Mach and inform him the ESD is not at the Bayview Library

3. The Letter is due Thursday (1.17.2) should include comments and questions

4. Letter should ask for extension because document was not made public, ESD should be discussed at January RAB meeting, and an extension to allow RAB TAPP grant contractor to review ESD, in order to better understand contamination test beyond 10 feet.

Soil Vapor Extraction (SVE)

Current contract: Navy is required to dig out soil around Building #126, no cost estimated in ESD document

Navy proposed changes: use SVE to suck out contamination from soil, no cost estimated in ESD document

Unanswered questions/concerns:

State and federal regulators go along with SVE

No long-term monitoring plan, will the Navy test for fugitive emissions?

Need for better site characterization, the source of contamination not well defined

Continue questions/concern:

How much contamination is in the soil? Not defined in Navy document

What will be the hours of operation? Noise impacts?

What is the cost of current contract? Cost of proposed changes?

Navy Clean Up Updates

Legal team check-in meeting will be at the end of the month and coordinated by ARC

Topics to be discussed will be the ESD, Navy Emergency Actions, Prop 65 suit

Clean up will focus on landfill data gap projects first than proposed project to expand cap

NEXT: Arc set-up meeting and circulating agenda

MOA- early Transfer of Shipyard to City

· The Navy and City have been meeting to discuss early transfer

· Meetings schedule: January 10, 17, 24 (in DC). The first meeting Navy proposed plan, second meeting Navy will respond to City counter proposal

· Documents in circulation: Navy proposal, City Amendments to Navy plan. Olin and Saul have reviewed and Navy‚s proposal has no performance schedule and the City‚s plan includes no language of development. Under the proposal parcel by parcel will be transferred

NEXT

CFC gets copies of both Navy proposal and City counter proposal

Early transfer workshop on 1.18.01 at Advocates office from 1-5pm

Redevelopment Community Benefits Contract

CBE and its consultant team will be interviewed on Wednesday 16. The contractor will work with Agency, CAC, and residents to develop a community benefits package

Farallon Island Hearing- Department of Commerce is hosting a hearing to know if people want waste removed and how manage sanctuary. Lynne, Saul, Maurice plan on attending, Tuesday, January 15, 6:30pm

KPFA/KPOO Townhall meeting potential date: 2.23.02

PROPOSED AGENDA FOR EARLY TRANSFER WORKSHOP

1-5pm, 5021 Third St.

MOA developments 1pm-1:30

What is Early Transfer? 1:30- 2:15

- Parameters? Define? Examples? Models?

Discussion of a possible Community Assessment Plan 2:15-2:45

What CFC does not want 2:45-3:30

Process of Developing Position 3:30-4pm

City officials discussion 4pm-5pm